Written by: Hope Thomson, Senior Project Director at UNC-Chapel Hill School of Government EFC
Three pop-up sprinkler heads watering a sloped green lawn in the sunlight, creating a fine mist with a paved pathway and wooden posts blurred in the background.
Angelo DeSantis from Berkeley, US, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons 

Water and wastewater utilities function as public enterprises, recovering the costs of providing services through various rates and charges. Most revenues come from rates for service that are assessed each billing cycle. Rates can vary by how they are calculated, what utility factors they are based on, how they impact customer bills, and how they may affect utility revenues. Both the structure of the rate and the actual dollar amount assigned to that structure have an impact on the utility’s revenues and the customer’s bill.  

Remember, considering rate options is most impactful once the utility has already determined a revenue target that the rates will aim to reach. Revisit the prior blog in this series to refresh your memory on revenue targets if needed. 

Scenario: Setting Rates with Scotch Bonnet 

The fictional Town of Scotch Bonnet, North Carolina has completed their revenue target planning process, and now they are ready to consider rate options for their utility. They have 483 connections and need to recover $500,000 annually from rates to pay for day-to-day operations and capital improvements. 

First, Scotch Bonnet is considering how they charge for services. The town is not considering just one number – they are thinking about how to structure their charges to meet utility goals and best serve customers. 

Paying for Access 

In a utility system, the goal for service is to be available 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and 365 days a year. This service is available without explicit customer requests – it is designed and maintained to be used without much interaction between the service providers and the users. This is a high degree of convenience, and there are costs associated with keeping services so consistent.  

Paying for access to the utility system gives the customer the ability to use this service when they would like. A rate based only on paying for access is not responsive to the amount of water that a customer uses – everyone pays for access to the system via a flat rate, or fixed fee, every billing cycle. Calculating this fee can be simple. A utility would divide the revenue target by the number of customers paying for access. 

For Scotch Bonnet, there is a revenue target of $500,000 annually, and 483 customers. To find a flat rate, they divide $500,000 by 483 and find an annual charge of $1,035.20 per customer. With a monthly billing cycle, divide that number by 12 to get a monthly flat rate of $86.27 per customer.  

Flat rates are simple to administer and bring in stable, predictable revenue. The tradeoff is fairness and conservation. A single-person household pays the same as a large family or a business, and no one sees a lower bill for using less water. 

Paying for Volume 

Customers are also paying for units of product – gallons of clean drinking water and gallons of wastewater removed and safely treated. There are costs associated with producing more of these units of product, including increased chemicals and electricity costs. Infrastructure is also sized specifically to meet customer demand. When paying for volume, there is a direct relationship between the amount of product used, and the customer’s bill. These are volumetric, or variable charges, charging an amount per unit of volume. A rate based only on payment for volume divides the revenue target by the total amount of water or wastewater billed in a year. 

For the Town of Scotch Bonnet, they bill customers for about 28 million gallons of water per year. With their $500,000 revenue target, they divide the total revenue target by their total gallons billed and find a volumetric rate of $17.86 per thousand gallons. Scotch Bonnet is careful to use gallons billed rather than gallons produced. Water lost to leaks, flushing, or unmetered uses never shows up on a customer’s bill, so dividing by production would set the rate too low to reach the revenue target. 

Volumetric charges can vary in how they are presented but are often in dollars per thousand gallons or dollars per hundred cubic feet. There are other units that are common to water volumes, but consider how they are measurable by your equipment, intuitive to your staff, and understood by your customers: an acre-foot of water, though sometimes used in the sector, is hard to conceptualize in terms of household use.  

A note – a hundred cubic feet (ccf) is equal to about 748 gallons! To convert from ccf to gallons, just multiply by 748. To convert from gallons to ccf, divide by 748. 

Relying solely on volumetric charges can have unexpected consequences for your utility’s revenues – remember, charges vary with usage. Consider a customer in Scotch Bonnet who is fond of their lush lawn. Their bill may be low in the winter, but skyrocket in the hot summer months. However, in a rainy July, they may skip watering their lawn, bringing their bills down and negatively impacting the utility’s revenue. This volatility may be challenging for utilities to manage, as costs to provide service stay largely constant regardless of gallons sold. Volumetric charges are directly related to water use, and so will be higher for larger water users. If the Town of Scotch Bonnet uses a purely volumetric strategy, their customers using a lot of water – the local car wash, greenhouse, coffee shop – will see higher bills than a typical residential user.  

Combining the Approaches: Fixed and Variable 

These strategies are often blended. There are both fixed and variable costs, and so using both fixed and variable charges can help a utility reliably cover costs as usage changes. For customers, the impact is twofold: they can understand the impact of their usage on the utility system from the volumetric portion and can have a degree of predictability in their bill from the fixed portion. It can often be difficult to completely cover fixed costs with fixed charges, and variable costs with volumetric charges, but using a blended structure can still provide multiple benefits to both customers and the utility.  

The Town of Scotch Bonnet is considering this option. First, they consider an approach attempting to cover each type of cost with the corresponding revenue type. They examine their budget and split their expenses into fixed and variable costs. Fixed costs are consistent no matter the volume of water produced and include things like debt service, salaries and benefits, software licenses, envelopes and mail, the telephone bill, and more. The variable costs are mostly the water treatment facility’s electric bill and chemicals.  

Town personnel determine that $350,000 of costs are fixed and $150,000 are variable. To find the fixed portion of the bill, the Town of Scotch Bonnet will divide the fixed portion of the revenue target by the number of connections: $350,000/483 connections = $724.64 annually, or $60.39 for a monthly base fee.  

The variable rate  is the same math as before but with a different revenue target of $150,000 – so $150,000 divided by 28 million gallons billed per year gives a volumetric rate  of $5.36 per thousand gallons.  

This is just one option – the Town does not have to set rates that correspond so directly to fixed and variable costs if they want to use the blended strategy. They could set a base fee that is more in line with what they see as reasonable for their customers to pay – say, $35 a month. With 483 customers, they can expect an annual base fee revenue of $35*483*12 = $202,860. Now they just need to calculate what the volumetric rate should be to recover the rest of their costs ($500,000-$202,860= $297,140). They can divide that target by the number of gallons billed to find a new volumetric rate of $10.61 per thousand gallons.  

More Decisions to Make 

These are just some of the strategies that Scotch Bonnet (and your utility) can use when setting rates. In the next installment of this series, we will discuss other components of rate setting, including volumetric blocks and other rate options for consideration.  

Additional Resources